| Franchise |
QB | RB | WR | TE | PK | Def |
| The Football Experts | Cutler, J Edwards, T | Faulk, K Johnson, L Norwood, J Turner, M Williams, R | Berrian, B Brown, R Floyd, M Henderson, D Holt, T Moss, S | Miller, B Olsen, G | Carney, J | Bills, B Saints, N |
| BigB | Frerotte, G Garcia, J Orton, K Rosenfels, S | Buckhalter, C McAllister, D McFadden, D Slaton, S Thomas, P Westbrook, B | Bryant, A Edwards, B Holmes, S Ocho Cinco, C | Fasano, A | Longwell, R | Buccaneers, T Titans, T |
| whodey | Campbell, J Manning, P | Benson, C Betts, L Brown, R Charles, J McGahee, W Morris, S | Bradley, M Breaston, S Gonzalez, A Jenkins, M Johnson, A Moss, R | Cooley, C | Kasay, J | Bears, C Cardinals, A |
| BPOW | Rivers, P Romo, T | Addai, J Bell, T Forte, M Jones, T | Chambers, C Hester, D Reed, J Stallworth, D Toomer, A Welker, W | Boss, K Gates, A | Bironas, R Crosby, M | Cowboys, D Giants, N |
| NEBULLI | Garrard, D Pennington, C | Portis, C Rhodes, D Smith, K Taylor, C | Colston, M Jackson, V Johnson, B Randle El, A Wayne, R Williams, R | Heap, T Winslow, K | Elam, J Kaeding, N | Jets, N Steelers, P |
| Gannz | Delhomme, J Thigpen, T | Bush, R Gore, F Jacobs, B Stewart, J Young, S | Avery, D Mason, D Royal, E Walter, K White, R Williams, R | Keller, D Stevens, J | Akers, D | Redskins, W |
| Matt Millen Hate Club | Hill, S Rodgers, A Schaub, M | Foster, D Jackson, S Johnson, C Ward, D Williams, C | Bowe, D Branch, D Cotchery, J Fitzgerald, L Marshall, B | Carlson, J Miller, H | Hartley, G | Patriots, N Ravens, B |
| Ozark Thunder | Manning, E Ryan, M | Grant, R Hightower, T McClain, L Peterson, A | Boldin, A Evans, L Ginn Jr., T Hilliard, I Hixon, D Johnson, C Jones, M Smith, S | Gonzalez, T Miller, Z | Gostkowski, S | Panthers, C |
| The Spoilers | Favre, B Roethlisberger, B | James, E Johnson, R Parker, W | Baskett, H Coles, L Crayton, P Curtis, K Harrison, M Muhammad, M | Shockey, J Spaeth, M Watson, B | Gould, R Reed, J | Browns, C Packers, G |
| Raiders Rejects | Brees, D Russell, J | Barber, M Fargas, J Jones, F Jones, J Jones, K Jones-Drew, M Washington, L | Bruce, I Jennings, G Ward, H | Clark, D Lewis, M | Folk, N Janikowski, S | Colts, I Eagles, P |
| Phinz | Hasselbeck, M McNabb, D Orlovsky, D | Dunn, W Graham, E Harrison, J Jackson, F Lewis, J Lynch, M | Clayton, M Driver, D Gage, J Houshmandzadeh, T Owens, T | Daniels, O | Vinatieri, A | Chargers, S Dolphins, M |
| HITLER'S REVENGE | Cassel, M Wallace, S Warner, K | Choice, T Sproles, D Tomlinson, L Williams, D | Bess, D Jackson, D Moore, L Smith, S | Scheffler, T Witten, J | Brown, J Lindell, R | Raiders, O Vikings, M |